Fishslap's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Identity (2006)]

My opinion

It was nicely done, yadda yadda.

But it really felt like it wasn't. I'm sure you'll get a good grade, but to me the style pretty sucked. It seemed poorly animated and the sound effects were more annoying. I'm not a masochist, I do not enjoy making myself digusted, but the toilet scene just felt like it really pushed that. It had little plot, little action, and if you're going to make something based purely on style I'd much rather it was a nice style. But no, I see a frame by frame person's life go crappy in a pretty boring nasty way. And so I think it has all too little artistic merit or entertainment, and has now been given an official "crap" rating from me.

And don't go angry, it's my honest view, if you want an argument moan at the people who can't decide whether it's a dog or cat or whatever the hell it is.

Peda responds:

hehe, thanks for your views. I am not angry, just upset that you didnt enjoy it- it was experimental afterall, these things happen.
And if im going to argue- its with people who for no good reason make suck-ass, dumb-shit reviews like 'THAT SUX. U SUCK LOL WAS CRAAAAAAPPP!!1!!'... if u know what i mean. thank you for the review :)

[So much]

Awesome...

The solid best music-video flash I have seen. The graphics obviously aren't from an artist, but credit for that as the animation was superb compared, and you have spent a lot of effort on this compared to most ng submissions.

ReporterClock responds:

=| thanks, but... "obviously aren't form an artist"? I'm sorry but that is an insult. I am an artist and I've been drawing ever since Ic an remember myself.